From: Mats Bergstrom <matsb@sos.sll.se>
Date: Fri, 22 Apr 94 03:00:12 PDT
To: eff-talk@eff.org
Subject: Re: Pearl Harbor
In-Reply-To: <Co5n0x.LI9@apollo.hp.com>
Message-ID: <Pine.3.85.9404221117.A28793-0100000@cor.sos.sll.se>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain



 12 Apr 1994, Bill Sommerfeld wrote:

(about the strategical impact of codebraking in WWII)

> Sources: the book "Bodyguard of Lies".  Unfortunately, my copy of the
> book is at home; I don't recall the name of the author, but it's a
> book on deception campaigns in World War II; the title is a shortened
> form of the (approximate) quote "In wartime, the truth is protected by
> a bodyguard of lies".

With some effort I found that book deep inside my private library.
By Anthony Cave Brown, 1975. It has been a while since I read it but
I recollect that it is a straightforward tale of spying and deception
incidents without much of a critical analysis.

For those who want to read a rather different conclusion (i.e. negative)
regarding the importance of the spooks in WWII (and whatever) I warmly 
recommend:

The Second Oldest Profession
by Phillip Knightley, 1986.

Some quotes from the cover description:

He shows how, once it had gained a toehold within a single government
bureaucracy, the espionage industry expanded remorselessly and firmly
established itself at the very heart of the modern state.

Do they make any difference - even in wartime?

Over the years intelligence work has probably attracted more con-men,
fantasists and sheer incompetents than any other field of human 
endeavour and, stripped of their mystique, the secret world and the
antics of its inhabitants are as much the stuff of farce as of
melodrama.