1995-10-13 - Re: NYT on Internet Flaws

Header Data

From: David HM Spector <spector@zeitgeist.com>
To: Vincent Cate <vince@offshore.com.ai>
Message Hash: 02e1f106a2f950132c63ca5a6e9cf01fac9d5cac5baf31c05a04815dd37c00df
Message ID: <199510130119.VAA02267@zeitgeist.zeitgeist.com>
Reply To: <Pine.3.89.9510121633.A6162-0100000@offshore.com.ai>
UTC Datetime: 1995-10-13 01:20:14 UTC
Raw Date: Thu, 12 Oct 95 18:20:14 PDT

Raw message

From: David HM Spector <spector@zeitgeist.com>
Date: Thu, 12 Oct 95 18:20:14 PDT
To: Vincent Cate <vince@offshore.com.ai>
Subject: Re: NYT on Internet Flaws
In-Reply-To: <Pine.3.89.9510121633.A6162-0100000@offshore.com.ai>
Message-ID: <199510130119.VAA02267@zeitgeist.zeitgeist.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain




The real problem seems to be that Markoff (with whom I have spoken
often in the past, and is actually *IS* a competent reporter -- usually)
seems to have taken a number of interviews with various people and
combined them, out of order with no real context into an Internet
boogey-man story.

The reason I say this is simply from the quotes by Jeff Schiller (and
the "Netscape spokesman") -- they were most certainly talking about
the recent discovery of problems with Netscape.  The "NFS" silliness,
and the thought that NFS is the mechanism by which  Internet  users
download files seems to been have stiched in for the scare value.
(We won't even get into the real-time file hijacking, etc.)

I am suprised that Jeff Schiller isn't all over this (and other lists)
spitting bullets considering the way he was (mis)quoted.

On the other hand, it could well be that John wrote a different story
and his *editors* at the NY Times decided with, um, how to put this
delicately... re-ordered the story.. um, er I mean edited it.  It
happens all the time to make stories more "effective."  (Most old
newpaper folks are scared to death of this technology and take what
swipes at it they can, whenever they can.)

BTW: If you're really unhappy with Markoff, let him know what you
think of his reporting... his email addresses used to be:

	       markoff@nyt.com and johnm@well.sf.ca.us
	

regards,
  David


PS: Whatever I just said is my opinion, which should be obvious, since
its coming from my home machine(s) which are funded by me
personally... and not whomever I happen to work for from 9 to 5...

PPS: BTW John, in case you're reading this, (and anyone else) you DO
NOT HAVE PERMISSION TO QUOTE ME... period!  In fact, this posting is
Copyright (c) 1995 by David HM Spector and may not be reprinted in
whole or in part without my express written permission.  I have a
copyright lawyer; she's really good, on retainer, and loves a good
brawl....
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
David HM Spector				Software Developer & Nice Guy
http://zeitgeist.com				spector@zeitgeist.com
voice: +1 212.721.6974				fax: +1 212.721.9084
                               --------
SJM, 32, seeks SJF for meaningful rel... What? This ISN'T the VOICE personals?!






Thread