From: Tom.Jennings@f111.n125.z1.FIDONET.ORG (Tom Jennings)
Date: Tue, 27 Oct 92 06:25:26 PPE
To: cypherpunks@toad.com
Subject: re: Registering Keys...
Message-ID: <3336.2AED0EE9@fidogate.FIDONET.ORG>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain



 U> From: 74076.1041@CompuServe.COM (Hal)

 U> This proposal to register keys was also mentioned in the 
 U> July, 1992 Communications of the ACM, in an article by Ron 
 U> Rivest, one of the creators of the RSA algorithm.  He was 

 U> solution based on 'escrowed secret keys' might be 
 U> workable, wherein each user is legally required to depost 
 U> his or her secret key with a trusted third party, such as 
 U> the user's bank.


Actually this sounds signifigantly different from what Denning is
allegedly proposing.

This method is analogous to the way FFL (Federal Firearm License)
holders record transactions of gun sales (I have an FFL). FFL holders
are required to record, in detail, each transaction based upon gun
serial number/description, and to/from addresses (buy/sell). The FFL
holder maintains the records; the feds dont' get a copy.

If a gun is used in a crime, the feds go to the manufacturer, and
follow the audit trail of FFL records to follow that guns travels.

This is *completely* different than a centralized gun database, where
a hypothetical they can compile cross indices based upon oh say name
or address or whatever. 

The third party escrow method puts the same sort of restraint upon
searches. I'm not saying I particulary like the method, it's just that
it's qualitatively different. The BATF cannot rummage through the
audit trail of FFL records, they can only follow the forward/backward
pointers per gun. Rivest seems to imply there could be many,
independent key-escrow locations. A hypothetical we could form our own
key escrow, and while we'd be subject to whatever the hypothetical
they would require for access, we could probably do things ilke inform
members of all key accesses/inquiries, etc.

In short, it bothers me a lot less than Dennings.

--- ReadMail
 * Origin: World Power Systems / FidoNews / San Francisco CA (1:125/111)
--  
Tom Jennings - via FidoNet node 1:125/555
    UUCP: ...!uunet!hoptoad!kumr!fidogate!111!Tom.Jennings
INTERNET: Tom.Jennings@f111.n125.z1.FIDONET.ORG