From: roy@sendai.cybrspc.mn.org (Roy M. Silvernail)
Date: Wed, 6 Jul 94 22:18:22 PDT
To: cypherpunks@toad.com
Subject: Re: Counting bits
In-Reply-To: <9407070147.AA11105@prism.poly.edu>
Message-ID: <940706.224045.2s5.rusnews.w165w@sendai.cybrspc.mn.org>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

In list.cypherpunks, rarachel@prism.poly.edu writes:

> 
> Why bother when you can simply do an eight line function?
> 
> int bitcount(char b)
> {
> register int retval=0;
> 
>  if (a & 1) retval++;
>  if (a & 2) retval++;
>  if (a & 4) retval++;
>  if (a & 8) retval++;
>  if (a & 16) retval++;
>  if (a & 32) retval++;
>  if (a & 64) retval++;
>  if (a & 128) retval++; 
> 
> return retval;
> }
> 
> This function, (if you have a decent compiler) will be turned into about 32
> instructions at most.

Just for entertainment value, I clipped your function and compiled it
with Turbo C++ 1.01 in default (ANSI C) mode.  Here's the .asm code
produced (comments and setup code edited for brevity)

_bitcount	proc	near
	push	bp
	mov	bp,sp
	push	si
	mov	dl,byte ptr [bp+4]
	xor	si,si
	test	dl,1
	je	short @1@74
	inc	si
@1@74:
	test	dl,2
	je	short @1@122
	inc	si
@1@122:
	test	dl,4
	je	short @1@170
	inc	si
@1@170:
	test	dl,8
	je	short @1@218
	inc	si
@1@218:
	test	dl,16
	je	short @1@266
	inc	si
@1@266:
	test	dl,32
	je	short @1@314
	inc	si
@1@314:
	test	dl,64
	je	short @1@362
	inc	si
@1@362:
	test	dl,128
	je	short @1@410
	inc	si
@1@410:
	mov	ax,si
	jmp	short @1@434
@1@434:
	pop	si
	pop	bp
	ret	
_bitcount	endp

Your estimate was a little short.  I count 35 instructions. :-)
- -- 
Roy M. Silvernail --  roy@sendai.cybrspc.mn.org will do just fine, thanks.
          "Does that not fit in with your plans?"
                      -- Mr Wiggen, of Ironside and Malone (Monty Python)
        PGP 2.3a public key available upon request (send yours)

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.6

iQCVAwUBLht6nBvikii9febJAQELawP9GFgXQ8HMKoiIWgRDH6oLYxHfz8XMsKEN
I3BXCpqwe35ADBP6ah8vgEWfifOJMIlduR02u8RV/Zz4ROC0kRBrJPw/Gk7R3gd5
uoUlqUgjZQAmqNcBE84hTHqxnLmSKJJb3nygYVZ8fhA6Fhn0BJ/6hpRuAGazN3B0
SVznWIhxpmQ=
=tPEz
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----