From: "Alexander 'Sasha' Chislenko" <sasha1@netcom.com>
Date: Tue, 9 Jan 96 19:24:17 PST
To: cypherpunks@toad.com
Subject: PRIVACY: Private traces in public places
Message-ID: <2.2.32.19960110032650.006f1934@netcom.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain


  Most of the materials that are currently available on the Net and
can be easily found through many search engines were created
for other media, by people who were not aware that these materials
may ever end up on the Web.
  Sometimes, it comes as an unpleasant surprise to a person who
looks for web pages referencing his own name, and finds, among
other things, many of his explicit or controversial usenet or mailing
list messages, old resumes that may contradict the current one,
critical remarks of his high school girlfriend and former colleagues, etc.
Knowing that this information is easily accessible to his new girlfriend
and prospective employer may make him more than uncomfortable.

All advice to such a person you may see on the Net mentions Net laws
that should have been passed and personal actions that should or
should not have been taken.

In both cases, it's usually too late.

Fortunately, not that many people have been burned.
We can bury them (or their reputations) and move ahead, vowing not
to repeat their mistakes.  From now on we, the prudent ones, will be
very careful not to leave compromising traces where they can be
uncovered by existing technologies and made public.

It's called "learning from other people's mistakes".

- No, it isn't !

The mistake those people made was not leaving traces that could be made
public with *then* existing technologies.  It was doing things that could be
uncovered by technologies (like search engines) that at the time *did not
exist*.

If you want to learn from these mistakes, you should look at what information
about yourself you are leaving behind that can be made public tomorrow.

Let's look at what traces you leave.  

 I do not want to consider time travelers from the future watching your life.
- Just some already available technologies that are on the rise and will be
cheap and ubiquitous tomorrow.


- Your database records.
- All letters to public officials that you ever wrote or that mentioned your
name.
- All mentions of you in any printed press.
- All published photos where you can be recognized (including street crowds,
  demonstrations, football games) - they will all be scanned some day, and
  machines with image recognition will find you even where you wound't.

- Your fingerprints.  How many books, magazines and other things currently
  stored all over the world carry your fingerprints?  It is possible to
figure out
  what pages you read, after whom, with whom, etc.

- Landfills:  They are probably the richest source of detailed historical
information
   that is not obtainable from any other source and can be used to reconstruct
   the detailed history of society, economy, technology and any single
person with
   incredible detail.

  Besides thousands of your personal letters and documents, they contain data on
  the evolution of your intelligence,  handwriting, habits such as
nail-biting, samples
  of hair that you washed with different shampoos (or didn't) and millions
of discarded
  little things identifiable by your writing, fingerprints or DNA samples.
One may figure
  out where you drank a cup of Coke 30 years ago,  and who you shared it with.

  And so on.

  The technology necessary to recover and index all this data is already
available
and will become very cheap in a few decades.

How can people protect themselves from all this?

Will people of the future all wear identical privacy suits, gloves and
helmets and burn
everything they have touched?

Or they will just try not to do things they may later be ashamed of?
(How do you know what you may be ashamed of 30 years from now?)

----------------------------------------------------------
Alexander 'Sasha' Chislenko <sasha1@netcom.com>
Home page:  http://www.lucifer.com/~sasha/home.html
Great Thinkers page:  http://www.lucifer.com/~sasha/thinkers.html