From: Greg Broiles <gbroiles@netbox.com>
Date: Tue, 18 Feb 1997 07:26:14 -0800 (PST)
To: Anil Das <das@razor.engr.sgi.com>
Subject: Re: Message-Id / mail2news gateways.
Message-ID: <199702181526.HAA05746@toad.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

At 08:59 PM 2/17/97 -0800, Anil Das wrote:

>1) Please preserver Message-Ids while resending messages.

Yes, this is absolutely crucial if many different systems are going to
cooperatively deal with messages. Message-ID changing is very bad. I sent a
Perl script to Lance (copies to others on request) which can be easily used
as the target of an /etc/aliases entry to gate a mailing list into inews (and
thereby into INN) for processing as a netnews message. (The script preserves
Message-ID.) If we preserve Message-ID's, many sites can have local mail-news
gateways, and we won't (globally) see duplicates. 

>2) In response to Igor's query, I would very much like at least
>on of the distributed lists to be set up such that messages sent
>there will *not* be gatewayed to Usenet.

I don't think this is practical - as I understand things, the corpus (bolus?)
of messages will be available to all comers for their own projects, which may
include mail-news gateways, archives, filtered lists, and so forth(*). People
who send messages to the list shouldn't expect that they'll have any
"privacy" in information sent there. 

(* Modulo copyright, but apparently the industry standards for copyright
issues are:

1.	Ignore them and hope they go away
2.	Pretend to seize control over IP rights of everything posted

neither of which works very well or makes any sense, legally speaking.)

For what it's worth, the list has been gated to two public newsgroups -
albeit not in the Big 7 or alt. - for quite some time. If you think your name
isn't on Usenet, and you've been sending messages to the list, think again.


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 4.5

iQEVAgUBMwl1KP37pMWUJFlhAQHr+Qf+Jpo20Rl9RWAtsWFu7uJ2TYvIySYxrqCi
A0Ac54oQSuuzYV6diH+pddilzTSjNS9DgVRC/lkC1C64cIZLp9fb1I3gX25Wfyns
DnUvXPRLAD3A54imgkVxojr3ywD8YIn1QqQlVfh2yazJ6ysf0rFgQFcm3mMZxDqx
3MTl5x4sFo/CQPmYtGamZXEC59U2KW3iOaMiIESX3BjaK/92w9ptP44L0KqNcFqI
tpNlUwmjXlqi1CTInVnVUHT79pF/OCYwxzbb0hPL4OcSlEZGPcj8cf/KGKL3cyBp
hzIgjGPlfklXjCbvGBwi/9NUJEu9ARJVM+4Ie6ajDQWlzgPTO7w2zw==
=wifQ
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--
Greg Broiles                | US crypto export control policy in a nutshell:
gbroiles@netbox.com         | 
http://www.io.com/~gbroiles | Export jobs, not crypto.
                            |