1998-02-28 - With Respect to the Japanese

Header Data

From: bill payne <billp@nmol.com>
To: merata@pearl.sums.ac.ir
Message Hash: 636460abc7dcb4788c5cfb4e81cd75c83629b3baf33848a200ca2d6dbf2ddc25
Message ID: <34F75FD2.2084@nmol.com>
Reply To: N/A
UTC Datetime: 1998-02-28 00:55:52 UTC
Raw Date: Fri, 27 Feb 1998 16:55:52 -0800 (PST)

Raw message

From: bill payne <billp@nmol.com>
Date: Fri, 27 Feb 1998 16:55:52 -0800 (PST)
To: merata@pearl.sums.ac.ir
Subject: With Respect to the Japanese
Message-ID: <34F75FD2.2084@nmol.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain

Friday 2/27/98 5:27 PM


After Sandia unloaded on me for TRYING to be friendly with a 
Japanese [and perhaps other things too] , I enrolled in the UNM 
US-Japan program.

One of the professors in the program is Jack Condon.

   name: John Carl Condon
   work_phone: 505 277-5811
   title: Professor
   organization: Communication & Journalism
   org_address: C & J Building

Condon teaches both at the University of New Mexico and
a Japanese University.

Condon is a very nice touchy-feely-type person.

Condon wrote [amazon.com]
                            With Respect to the Japanese
                            by John C. Condon
                            List: $12.95
                            Our Price: $12.95

                            Availability: This title is currently on
back order. We do
                            not have a reprint date for this title, but
we expect to be
                            able to ship it to you within 3-5 weeks.

                            Published by Intercultural Press
                            Publication date: June 1983
                            ISBN: 0933662491

Condon told our class,

   The US does not do very well without an enemy.

So.  Let's do OUR BEST to insure that that US does
not do very well, at least with Iran.

And Merat, another of my former Ph D students in Computer
Science is

   name: John Sobolewski
   work_phone: 505 277-8125
        title: Assoc VP,Info Technology
  organization: CIRT - Administration
  org_address: 2701 Campus Blvd NE
  email: jssob@unm.edu

Let's all hope this mess gets settled.


Title: UNM Computer and Information Resources and Technology (CIRT)

How to get quick help: Answers to frequently asked questions, Help Desk, publications and documentation, 
who to contact, CIRT hours.

What CIRT can do for you: Details about our services such as computing
facilities (pods), help desk, consulting, hardware maintenance, security,
software distribution, computer accounts, training, conference support and much more.

Qu Pasa?
What's happening at CIRT: Announcements, important systems news, scheduled system availability,
major projects we've undertaken, technical directions and job opportunities.

About CIRT
Who we are and how we are organized: Our mission and vision, a map
of the CIRT building, CIRT group organization, the annual report,
our system configurations and standards.

Send us your ideas on how CIRT can improve services to the UNM community!

Comments to CIRT Publications: docs@unm.edu

Last Revised: 10/28/97

The University of New Mexico
Albuquerque, New Mexico USA
Copyright (c) 1995 The University of New Mexico.

Title: Welcome to the Japan America Society of New Mexico

        <img src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/crane.GIF"
        alt="Crane logo" width="127" height="138">
        color="#800080" size="5">JAPAN AMERICA SOCIETY OF
        NEW MEXICO
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/crane.GIF" alt="Crane logo" width="127" height="138">

Ohayoo Gozaimasu! 

Greetings and welcome to the Web site of
the Japan America Society of New
Mexico. The Board of Directors
and the Membership extend to you our desire that you visit the
"Land of Enchantment" and sample the
"chili-hot" welcome and hospitality shown here. The
vistas are broad; the cuisine superb. In a multi-cultural
environment, we embrace all that is the state, and wait to enfold
you as well! Please enjoy. Yoroshiku, onegai shimasu!

        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/cvr-pg2.gif" align="top" width="579" height="653">

        <a href="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/bg&miss.htm"
        name="Buttons"><img src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif"
        alt="single lantern image" align="middle" width="49"
        color="#800080" size="4">BACKGROUND AND MISSION
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        <font color="#800080"
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        color="#800080" size="4">MEMBERSHIP
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        color="#800080" size="4">BENEFITS
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        color="#800080" size="4">FUNDING
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        color="#800080" size="4">CONTACT INFORMATION
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        color="#800080" size="4">FUTURE EVENTS
        src="http://www.us-japan.org/jasnm/s-lant4.gif" alt="single lantern image"
        align="middle" width="49" height="50">
        color="#800080" size="4">PAST EVENTS

Friday February 27, 1998 3:15 PM

By e-mail and US mail

Lieutenant General Kenneth A Minihan, USAF
Director, National Security Agency
National Security Agency
9800 Savage Road
Fort George G. Meade, MD 20755-6000

Dear General Minihan:

Purposes of the letter are to

1  request information under the Freedom of Information Act
2  explore settlement possibilities of our current lawsuit.

In about 1986 Sandia National Laboratories assigned me the 
task of  design and construction of a Comprehensive Test Ban 
Treaty seismic data authenticator.

In the initial stages of the project, Sandia cryptographer 
Gustavus Simmons attempted to convince both Sandia 
management and NSA employees Tom White, Mark Unkenholtz,
and Ed Georgio that a form of public key authentication should 
replace NSA employee Ronald Benincasa's National Seismic
Station/Unmaned Seismic Observatory 11-bit data authentication

My Sandia supervisor John Holovka and project leader H B [Jim]
Durham ordered me to write a paper explaining public key 

This paper,  RSA ENCRYPTION, along with my SAND report
describing my implementation of Benincasa's algorithm and
filings in our lawsuit, now appear on Internet at
http://www.jya.com/index.htm, click CRYPTOME, then OpEd,
then http://www.jya.com/whprsa.htm.

Sandia explored the merits of switching from Benincasa's
algorithm to a public key-based authentication method suggested
by Simmons.

For Sandia's evaluation of the merits of public key, electronic tagging,
and Bureau of Engraving and Printing projects ,  I bought for Sandia 
samples both the Cylink CY1024 and AT&T A & B two chip sets for
modulo m arithmetic computations.

NSA employee Tom White sent me a copy of the SECRET classified
NSA report on IBM's hardware public key chip FIREFLY.

I wrote in my tutorial paper

  RSA hardware computations

  The slow speed of software RSA computations plus the potential
  wide use prompted several companies to build chips which compute
  modular arithmetic to at least several hundred bits.  Most of
  these chips "cascade" to compute with a larger number of bits.

  Corporations involved in building these chips are

     1  IBM  Firefly

     2  AT&T

     3  Motorola (apparently a three chip set)

     4  Cylink   Pittway-First alert

     5  Sandia Labs (Algorithm M and predecessor chip)

  Details of the IBM chip is classified.  AT&T as of July 1987 has
  not released details of their chip.  Little information is
  available on the Motorola chip set.

  The Cylink chip is commercially available.  Its price dropped
  from $1,500 to $600 each in June 1987.  Data is transferred to
  and from the chip with serial shift register communication.

  The early Sandia chip was limited in speed.  The replacement
  chip is cascadeable, communicates with 8 or 16 bits parallel,
  matches the speed of the Cylink chip, but is not out of

  Rumors circulate that there is about an order of magnitude
  performance difference between some of these chips.

  These hardware chips improve exponentiation speed about 3 orders
  of magnitude over software implementation benchmarked on an Intel
  8086 family microcomputer.

Whitfield Diffie writes about both the Cylink and Sandia chips.  And
is quoted at  http://www.aci.net/kalliste/nukearse.htm.

Sandia had terrible luck with its public key chips.  

I reported SOME of the troubles to Electronic Engineering Times editor 
Loring Wirbel [http://techweb.cmp.com/eet/823/] on March 23, 1994.

        Dr. John Wisniewski was a supervisor at Sandia's Center for
        Radiation-hardened Microelectronics.  Wisniewski was a graduate
        student at Washington State University in about 1975.  I was a
        professor at WSU.

        Wisniewski knows all about the failing Sandia chips in the nuclear
        arsenal.  I took notes on February 13, 1993.  Wisniewski reviewed
        the problems again for me.

             1    No quality initiative.  Each chip lot had a different
             2    Overall yield - 40-50%.  Down to 10% after packaging.
             3    Metalization problems.  No planarization.  No flow of
                  glass.  Couldn't use high temperature.  Step coverage
                  problems.  Layed down over tension.  100% field returns
                  over several years.
             4    Sandia would store lots of parts for replacements.

        Sandia management made the decision to place low yield parts in
        the nuclear arsenal.  Sandia must meet DOD schedules management
        reasoned.  Hundreds of millions spent on CRM.  Sandia must show

        Wisniewski told me that low yield chip test survivors are those   
        whichthe tests failed to detect failures.  Wisniewski will talk.  
        503-625-6408.  Wisniewski now works for Intel in Oregon.  Have 
        Wisniewski tell you about the fire in the CRM clean room!

Sandia supervisor Jerry Allen later told me it cost $300,000 each to remove
Sandia's failing chips at Pantex from a nuclear bomb.

NSA apparently is biased toward hardware implementations of cryptographic
and authentication algorithms.  As opposed to software implementation.

NSA representatives and Sandia management decided not to use a public
key authentication scheme for its CTBT seismic data authenticator because
of all of the problems with implementing public key algorithms.

But NSA surely has spent MUCH MONEY on public key chip implementations.

NSA is promoting its Clipper crypto chips as described at 

And we get some information about technical specifications of NSA's Clipper
chip at http://www.us.net/softwar/http://www.us.net/softwar/clip.html

  Clipper Chip Information


     1 micron double level metal CMOS technology 
     0.35 watts power 
     28 pin plastic leaded chip carrier (PLCC) package 
     Transistor to transistor logic (TTL) interface 
     Chip ID, family key and device unique key are installed at 
     Chip ID, family key and device unique key are installed at programming           
     facility and are completely transparent to the user.

Therefore, Under the provision of the Freedom of Information Act, 
5 USC 552, I am requesting access to: 

1  Copies of all invoices from

	A   AT&T
	B   Motorola
	C   IBM
	D  Sandia National Laboratories

to NSA for payments for developing ANY public key-related chips between 
January 1, 1980 and February 27, 1998.

2  Copies of all invoices to NSA from ANY corporation involved in 
of ANY Clipper chip-related hardware between January 1, 1980 and 
February 27, 1998.

The public has a right to know how much NSA spent on TRYING monoploize the 
crypto business.

If there are any fees for searching for, or copying, the records I have 
requested, please inform me before you fill the request.

As you know, the Act permits you to reduce or waive the fees when the 
release of the information is considered as "primarily benefiting the 
I believe that this requests fits that category and I therefore ask that 
you waive any fees.

If all or any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific 
exemption(s) which you think justifies your refusal to release the information and inform me of your agency's administrative appeal procedures available to me under the law.

I would appreciate your handling this request as quickly as possible, and I 
look forward to hearing from you within 20 working days, as the law stipulates.

With respect to our current FOIA lawsuit, I feel that we should settle this
unfortunate matter.

I see from your biography at  http://www.nsa.gov:8080/ and
http://www.nsa.gov:8080/dirnsa/dirnsa.html that you are

         1979   Distinguished Graduate
         Master of Arts degree in National Security Affairs 
         Naval Postgraduate School 
         Monterey, California

One of my former M.S. and Ph.D students in Computer Science,
Ted Lewis, is currently the chairman of Computer Science at
Naval Postgraduate School [http://www.friction-free-economy.com/].

Small world.

But I think that this emphasizes that WE SHOULD all be on the same side.
Not engaged in a conflict in US federal court.  Or on Internet.

NSA attempts to withhold requested information are possibly unwise.  

In our wired world the aggrieved know what happened to them.
[http://www.aci.net/kalliste/speccoll.htm]. http://www.wpiran.org/,

And moderates in Iran, [http://persia.org/khatami/biography.html], appear 
want settlement too.

My family and I have been damaged by these crypto wars.

I ask you that consider fair settlement of damages caused by the National
Security Agency.

I cannot find your e-mail address on Internet.

Therefore I will forward the e-mail copy of this FOIA/settlement letter to 
Ray Kammer of NIST [http://www.nist.gov/], who along with the FBI 
[http://www.fbi.gov/, http://www.fbi.gov/fo/nyfo/nytwa.htmand], and NSA 
are trying to control the crypto business so that Kammer can possibly
forward an e-mail copy of the FOIA/Settlement letter to you.



William Payne
13015 Calle de Sandias
Albuquerque, NM 87111
505-292-7037 [I am not reading e-mail]