From: "Ernest Hua" <hua@teralogic-inc.com>
Date: Sat, 14 Nov 1998 07:08:01 +0800
To: <cypherpunks@cyberpass.net>
Subject: Re: Info Age Crime Terror and War
Message-ID: <01c001be0f54$4642b940$4164a8c0@mve21>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain



Tim May wrote:
> At 9:09 AM -0800 11/13/98, John Young wrote:
> > Senator Kyl has issued a long report, "Crime, Terror &
> > War: National Security and Public Safety in the Information
> > Age," ...
> >   http://jya.com/ctw.htm  (97K)
>
> I'll address one section, near the end of the report:
> ...

While I wholeheartly believe that the open-minded and interested
public would want to hear these mindless rants responded to with
some rationality and reason, I don't believe, for a moment that
Kyl & gang are serious about debating anything.  (Ok, there is a
TEENY chance he is just confused.)

My money on the claim that these are yet more rhetoric thrown
out to confuse as many people who are easily taken over by sound
bites as possible.  It's not as easy to explain the practical
reasons why crypto restrictions are unenforcible and unreasonable,
but it's easy to trumpet the national security cause and to raise
the spectre of police not being able to protect lil' Johnny and
Mary.

What I was hoping for from the pro-crypto ads was something like
this:

1.  Lil' Suzy writes E-Mail to Lil' Mary to meet at the mall at
    some well-lighted public place.
2.  Child molestor X intercepts E-Mail, but it's weak 40-bit
    encryption, and he breaks it.
3.  Mr. X forges E-Mail from Mary to Suzy changing the meeting
    location to some dark corner A, and forges E-Mail from Suzy
    to Mary changing the meeting locaiton to some dark corner B.
4.  Mr. X's co-conspirators, Mr. Y and Mr Z intercepts Mary and
    Suzy at the respective dark corners ... they scream for help
    ... no one answers at either location ... fade to black ...

This is the sort of stuff that would really counter the stupid
rhetoric from Sen. Kyl.

Ern