From: frissell@panix.com (Duncan Frissell)
Date: Fri, 12 Aug 94 04:16:32 PDT
To: Health Care Reform Discussion List <HEALTHRE@UKCC.uky.edu>
Subject: Re: Health Care Privacy Alert
Message-ID: <199408121115.AA19389@panix.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain


At 09:57 AM 8/10/94 EDT, Gerald M. Phillips, Ph.D. wrote:
>Posted for general interest

>Subject: Health Care Privacy Alert

>     The health care legislation proposed by Gephardt in the House and
>Mitchell in the Senate contains provisions which would establish a
>national health care data network and override most state medical
>confidentiality laws.  All health care providers, whether paid by
>insurance or not, will be required to provide the network with data
>from the patient medical record after every clinical encounter.


*Any* bill that passes will have all sorts of juicy, privacy-invading
provisions.

Leftists in the "privacy community" will have to decide which they like
better:  privacy or "health security."

There's no way you can have a government-directed, third-party-paid, health
care "system" without throwing privacy out the window.  Bureaucracies *keep*
records, they don't destroy them.  

Our president likes the "German System" -- 'nuff said.

DCF

"According to the CBO report on the 'Clinton-Mitchell Bill,' the effective
marginal tax rate on some lucky moderate income families ($20K-$30K) will be
85%(!) due to 1) ordinary taxes, (2) phase out of the earned income tax
credit, and (3) phase out of health insurance subsidies under the
'Clinton-Mitchell Bill'."