From: Mark Rogaski <wendigo@pobox.com>
Date: Thu, 19 Sep 1996 04:59:13 +0800
To: krenn@nym.alias.net (Krenn)
Subject: Re: Snake-Oil FAQ
In-Reply-To: <199609180001.UAA24489@anon.lcs.mit.edu>
Message-ID: <199609181500.LAA08399@charon.gti.net>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

An entity claiming to be Krenn wrote:
: 
: It would be nice to have a list of actual products which are deemed
: potential snake-oil. Such a list could be maintained anonymously
: through a nym to avoid all the annoying legal problems with commenting
: on another's product. Though truth is the best defense against libel
: charges, it would be very annoying to be sued or some such by some
: hairbrained snake-oil peddler.
: 

I think a blacklist of that sort is inherently bad.  I would much rather
have the public be able to RECOGNIZE SYMPTOMS of snake oil, rather than
just be spoon fed a list of good products vs. bad products.  Pardon the
cliche, but if you give a man a fish ... etc, etc.

mark

- -- 
    Mark Rogaski   | Why read when you can just sit and |      Member
  GTI System Admin |         stare at things?           | Programmers Local
  wendigo@gti.net  | Any expressed opinions are my own  |     # 0xfffe
 wendigo@pobox.com | unless they can get me in trouble. |     APL-CPIO

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.6.2

iQEVAwUBMkAOhBz4pZwIaHjdAQEe9wf8D2Dhp1vcv1W4aOiugeNrJTp7FoDIb3yo
62sq44c/vlBX/Ph6InrHP6zHIKG1gx6ipt1NLXGWDZV0hWGrn9Eu7dIATqHjoyoM
9oFK8c00Rlg63o/FVl2XUHovfbPolqOBX24MRngqrsyWdOyqdShSwVPTH5ZBUj5I
Pxp4BWjcjYqkfF7nKXaWitJs2wjaM4yYQ57UIe1Hm/SLLL2erxNfrveWN1VwrdyO
N3QIuHfPWM3yi+UUJTOybOKLp+j07bgs+mLr2MT9JmYYrYZwtTEwLD4a6oueUZpN
LLWaIS8vekEy7HSzhG7sPfo35v/aaKKWs739af3UgLd3HUdzmVvfgw==
=YK3C
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----